Broken Promise — On the Record
"Caps, Not Cuts."
He Said It on Camera. Then He Cut.
Mark Carney made a direct, unambiguous promise during the 2025 campaign: the public service would face spending caps, not job cuts. Federal workers and the Canadians who depend on their services were told their government would be managed — not dismantled. That promise is now worth nothing.
✓ The Promise — Campaign 2025
"Caps, not cuts. We are not going to cut the public service."
— Mark Carney, on camera, federal election campaign 2025
✗ The Reality — March 2026
12,000+ federal positions cut in the first wave alone. 57,000+ jobs projected gone by 2028. Termination notices already issued.
— Global News / Treasury Board departmental plans, March 21, 2026
On March 21, federal departments and agencies released their spending review plans for 2026–27, showing more than 12,000 full-time equivalent positions will be eliminated over the next three years. That is the first wave — the number drawn from departments that provided concrete details. Many departments submitted only vague commitments to "streamline" and "modernize," meaning the full picture is still hidden. When the complete tally is projected to 2028, the number exceeds 57,000 positions.
12,000+
FTE positions
cut — wave one
57,000+
Projected total
gone by 2028
11,800+
Termination
notices issued
$0
Savings returned
to Canadians
This is not a reorganization. This is not a cap. These are termination notices sent to real federal workers — people who process your tax returns, review your passport applications, staff your EI claims, inspect your food, and run health programs. Department by department, here is what has already been confirmed:
Canada Revenue Agency
Already lost 7,000. Could reach 14,000 total.
7,000–14,000
Health Canada
942 positions confirmed eliminated.
942+
Public Services & Procurement Canada
Winding down Canada General Standards Board; reducing Laboratories Canada.
1,793
Statistics Canada
850 positions cut.
850+
Environment & Climate Change Canada
Reducing the Low Carbon Economy Fund.
Unspecified
Library & Archives Canada
Reducing Access to Information and Privacy functions over three years.
Unspecified
Canadian Space Agency
Terminating the LEAP Lunar Rover Mission entirely.
Program cancelled
Canadian Food Inspection Agency
Reducing non-core research, consolidating lab services.
Unspecified
Conservative MP Stephanie Kusie, the Treasury Board critic, put it plainly: departments have updated their full-time equivalent numbers, "but we're still seeing an increase in spending." The jobs are being cut. The bill is going up. Canadians get worse service and pay more for it.
Where the "Savings" Are Actually Going
Public service jobs eliminated (wave one)
−12,000+ jobs
Projected total public service cuts by 2028
−57,000+ jobs
Military spending increase announced by Carney
+$80 Billion
Returned to Canadians as tax relief or service investment
$0
The savings from gutting the public service are not being returned to taxpayers. They are being redirected to a massive military spending increase — $80 billion — that Carney announced as part of his NATO commitments. Canadians are being asked to accept worse government services so that the same government can spend more on defence. That trade was never put to voters. The man who promised "caps, not cuts" did not campaign on this.
For Canadians who interact with the federal government — which is to say, all of us — here is what these cuts mean in practice:
→
CRA — Tax Filing and Processing
CRA has already lost 7,000 workers. If cuts double to 14,000, expect longer hold times, slower refund processing, and reduced capacity during tax season. The Digital Services Tax unit — which collected from tech giants — is being wound down entirely.
→
Passport and IRCC Processing
Public Services and Procurement Canada — which supports federal service delivery infrastructure — is losing 1,793 positions. The passport backlog crisis of 2022 has not been forgotten. The workforce that was rebuilt to address it is now being cut.
→
EI and Benefits Processing
Service Canada and Employment and Social Development Canada handle Employment Insurance. With fewer workers processing claims, Canadians who lose their jobs will wait longer for the benefits they paid into.
→
Health Canada and Food Safety
Health Canada is losing 942 positions. The Canadian Food Inspection Agency is cutting non-core research and consolidating labs. Less capacity to review drug approvals, monitor food safety, and respond to public health issues.
→
Access to Information
Library and Archives Canada is specifically reducing its Access to Information and Privacy functions. That is the mechanism Canadians and journalists use to hold the government accountable. It is being deliberately downsized.
Sharon DeSousa, PSAC National President
"By eliminating thousands of jobs, the government is weakening the very programs people in Canada rely on. The cuts aren't about efficiency — they're an attack on the public service itself."
— Public Service Alliance of Canada, March 21, 2026
Conservative MP Stephanie Kusie — Treasury Board Critic
"It makes me wonder, do they know what they're doing or are they not quite certain as of yet? I'm worried about it for transparency."
— On departmental plans that lack detail about which programs and services will be cut
Several departments submitted plans so vague that even the Treasury Board critic cannot determine what will actually be affected. Some said they were "still figuring out" where to find savings. That means the 12,000-job figure announced this week is a floor, not a ceiling — and the government does not appear to know the final number yet.
The Verdict
"Caps, not cuts" was a promise made on camera, to voters, during a federal election campaign. It was specific. It was unambiguous. It was false.
The public service is being cut. The services you depend on are getting worse. The money is going to the military. And the departments doing the cutting cannot even tell Parliament exactly what they are cutting yet.
This is not fiscal management. This is a broken promise, a hidden trade-off, and a government that believes it does not owe Canadians an explanation.